The Bornhuetter-Ferguson method, explained

The Bornhuetter-Ferguson (BF) method is a reserving technique that blends an a priori expected-loss estimate with the chain ladder. It is most useful for immature accident years, where the chain ladder alone over-reacts to a thin, volatile diagonal.

The intuition

The chain ladder leverages reported losses to project ultimates, which works well for mature years but becomes unstable when little has developed. BF addresses this by weighting between the chain ladder result and an a priori expectation (often an expected loss ratio times premium), using the expected percent reported as the weight.

Concretely, BF estimates ultimate losses as reported losses plus expected unreported losses, where the unreported portion is the a priori estimate multiplied by the proportion of losses still expected to emerge.

A worked example

Take an accident year with $10,000,000 of earned premium, an expected loss ratio of 65%, and $1,800,000 reported so far. The cumulative development factor to ultimate is 3.20.

The a priori ultimate is $10,000,000 × 65% = $6,500,000. A CDF of 3.20 means 1 / 3.20 = 31.25% of losses are expected to have been reported, so 68.75% are still to emerge.

BF puts the unreported losses at $6,500,000 × 68.75% = $4,468,750, which is the IBNR. The ultimate is $1,800,000 + $4,468,750 = $6,268,750.

The chain ladder alone would say $1,800,000 × 3.20 = $5,760,000. BF lands between the two because it is a weighted average: 31.25% on the chain ladder and 68.75% on the a priori. A young year mostly believes the plan, which is either reassuring or worrying depending on who wrote the plan.

When to use it

  • Immature accident years where the chain ladder is volatile.
  • Long-tailed lines where early development is sparse.
  • As a cross-check against the chain ladder and expected-loss-ratio methods.

When to be careful

  • The a priori is stale: a rate change, a mix shift or a new program since the plan was set moves the expected loss ratio, and BF will not notice.
  • The year is mature: BF converges on the chain ladder as the percent reported rises, so it adds little there.
  • The year is running hot or cold: BF ignores the year’s own experience in the unreported part, so a year well above plan still gets the plan’s IBNR.

Sources

  • [CAS, Exam 5 content outline](https://www.casact.org/exam/exam-5-basic-ratemaking-and-est-claim-liabilities)